I just watched Ken Burns’ new documentary about the role the United States played in the Holocaust.
In 1960, my life changed when I read the book and saw the movie, “Exodus.” The film, starring Paul Newman and directed by Otto Preminger, brought the Holocaust to life for a 16-year-old boy whose main interests were playing basketball and trying to understand girls.
The story of the Holocaust, which had ended just 14 years earlier, became a powerful influence in my life. The movie was a fictionalized story in which Newman portrays a young refugee in World War II fleeing by boat to Palestine. The story takes place just before Palestine became the new Jewish homeland for the remnant of the nine million Jews who lived in Germany, Poland and the rest of Europe, who since 1932 had been systematically murdered by Hitler and his followers.
I was incredibly naive in 1960. My parents never talked about the war in Europe and the Pacific. Their stories were about starting a screw machine shop in 1941 to avoid the draft. Making bullets and gun parts was how they fought the war. That was enough for me until I saw Ari Ben-Canaan, the name Newman’s character adopts when he changes from refugee to Israeli freedom fighter. We named our first son Ari, incidentally.
Israel became a consuming interest for me, and the Holocaust became more real, but the horror of six million Jews slaughtered was beyond my grasp.
Six million. Can anybody really grasp the titanic horror of six million real human beings systematically slaughtered?
The power of film gradually started to penetrate my psyche. When I went away to college, I watched the German film masterpiece, “Triumph of the Will,” by Leni Riefenstahl, Hitler’s girlfriend. It was chilling and powerful, giving me a sense of how a country could be transformed by brilliant propaganda into an evil killing mob.
I read The Diary of Anne Frank and saw one of the several movies portraying the story of the family in hiding in Amsterdam. Eventually, my family would walk through the house and see the hiding places.
Yet I was still so naive. I was an American. I always felt free and unthreatened despite encountering anti-Semitism on rare occasions.
As I think about it now, my interest in the Holocaust was so shallow, pathetically single-dimensional. But how does anybody who lived in the United States all of their life possibly have any real sense of gas chambers and crematoriums.
In 1998, my wife, Risa, decided to go on a tour of Poland with a friend that would attempt to bring to life pre-war living for Jews. I chose not to go but then went to Poland on a business trip and joined the group on their bus ride to Lublin and the Majdanek concentration camp directly adjacent to the city.
It was December, and it snowed while we rode the bus from Krakow.
When we finally arrived late in the day, everyone filed off the bus. I stayed, trying to grasp the moment of actually being at a concentration camp, a killing center, across the street from modern Lublin.
I left the bus eventually. Everybody else had gone in. It was snowing and cold. I took off my coat, my sweater, my shirt, and then my undershirt. I stood next to the bus, feeling the snow and cold on my skin. After a few minutes, I put my shirts and coat back on and walked into the main building. I read some of the names of the prisoners, looked at the tiny bunk beds and then walked into the shower area where the poison gas was fed through the shower heads. It was so plain, so sterile, so overwhelmingly terrifying.
And that is all I remember, except getting back on the bus and heading to the hotel. The memory of the shower heads still haunts me in my dreams.
I separated from the group and continued my business trip–I think. I can’t really remember much of anything else. Not too long afterwards, our whole family spent two months in Israel when the Millennium was celebrated.
Now we have the newest Ken Burns documentary about the United States during Holocaust. It is definitely worth watching. Grim, and informative. America took in 225,000 Jews after 1933. The State Department sat on its hands. In the ‘30s and ‘40s, the country did not want immigrants. Anti-Semitism was strong.
It is appalling. Six million Jews were killed. That is the equivalent death toll of September 11 happening every day for four years.
The Holocaust story is a major piece of my lifelong memory. And what does it matter in 2022? Who really cares except for the few survivors and the relatives?
Question:When have you been discriminated against? How did you handle it?
That was a very emotional experience reading this piece. I give you credit for laying open your soul like that.
I just recorded the documentary last night as I had forgotten about it and missed the first episode.
My goal is to learn about that time and how it could have ever come to that. The only movie I have seen about the Holocaust is “The Boy in the Striped Pajamas” but I need to see others including “Schindler’s List”.
The young people today just have no real knowledge about what transpired.
I am 67 and white and have never really felt discrimination (except for being short) my whole life. So I guess I don’t know what that must be like.
Thanks for having the guts to write about such a moving experience that you had.
Thanks for sharing Daniel.
I appreciate your honest perspective.
Lloyd – Strong piece. Your analogy … “That is the equivalent death toll of September 11 happening every day for four years, ” although horrifying, should bring the evils of 1933 -1945 closer to home for younger folks. I pray that the Holocaust is never forgotten.
Made me think if when I was younger I was teased all the time for being the smallest guy in high school class. But I didn’t let it bother me too much and got over it. It is sobering that Hitler’s regime could terminate the lives of 6 millions people, They all had a name and a face, and they were all Gods creation. But that number is small in comparison to the holocaust that is happening here in the U.S. Its called abortion, Hitler would have been proud of the abortionist here. Since Roe V Wade decision in 1973 there has been over 63 million babies killed. They all had a face, but maybe not a name. But all of them were the handy work of God. Our Constitution was created to protect our God given rights, The right to Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. 63 million lives here were not given the chance to experience that right. On 9-1101 over 3000 U.S. citizens died in the attacks that day, but really it was close to 7000 that day if you add the abortions. So every day since 1973 there has been a 9-11 going on in America abortion clinics. Maybe one of those aborted babies could have been someone who could have cured a bad disease, Or been another wright Brother on Edison. Let that sink in.
“The death of one man is a tragedy. The death of millions is a statistic.” – Josef Stalin
Thank you for baring your soul.
We do not teach history, or at least real history.
Thank you for reminding us of it.
“Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” – George Santayana, The Life of Reason, 1905. (Churchill borrowed and paraphrased it)
The horror and inhumanity.
I visited a death camp in Germany on a European vacation when I was a teenager.
I could not make sense of it at that time, and still have difficulty trying to understand how people could do such things. Yet I have learned there is much Evil in this world, and you must confront it.
We see it every day with the violence here in NYC.
Hard to fathom some 6 million potential for good gone up in smoke, literally.
As Stalin said: “…The death of millions is a statistic.”
And when we look at the statistics, since WWII, some 60 to 100 MILLION were exterminated by Communist regimes? If we kill a few more dissenters the great communist system will work great.
No one speaks or teaches of those deaths either. A tenfold atrocity years after Hitler’s heinous acts, without much of a whisper…
History just repeating itself…
Our youth has been brainwashed to believe that socialism is the greatest system ever, they just didn’t do it right in the past…
“The goal of socialism is communism.” – Vladimir Lenin
Too many of our current elected leaders proudly proclaim to be socialists – look at AOC.
Unfortunately she has no knowledge or understanding of history.
Is it naiveté, ignorance, willful denial, or just plain stupidity?
Try to tell them what the future could be under Communism, and they scoff and laugh.
Look at how China just welded the doors of occupied buildings closed to quarantine people for suspected WuFlu. Not much mention on the nightly propaganda channel , I mean news station.
People better wake up!
Sad to say: HISTORY REPEATS ITSELF!!!
KEEP TEACHING Lloyd!
It may be an incredibly sad irony that Covid began in a Chinese lab funded partly by Americans. Perhaps this why they fear it so desperately.